Deportation & Community Resistance

    Overview

    Download Lesson

    Deportation & Community Resistance

    As immigration enforcement becomes more aggressive, schools have become increasingly risky places for undocumented students.

    Author: Victoria Thanh Nguyễn Huỳnh
    Grades: 9-12

    Suggested Amount of Time: 60 - 90 Minutes
    Area of Study: Vietnamese Resettlement and Community Building

    Compelling Question
    • What is Vietnamese America?

    Lesson Questions
    • How have the criminal legal system and immigration system impacted Vietnamese communities? 
    • How have Vietnamese and Southeast Asian refugees challenged deportation in their communities?
    Lesson Objective

    Students will trace the relationships and make connections between refugee trauma, criminalization, community organizing, and collective healing by critically evaluating narratives of assimilation or the model minority and engaging with primary source materials to create an infographic.

    Lesson Background

    Vietnamese refugees are among one of the largest community groups to flee to the United States. Among resettlement into the United States, they had to endure challenges such as: poverty, post-traumatic stress disorders, exposure to crime and gang violence, and much more. A staggering number of refugees have been met with deportation orders to return to Vietnam, although they have been raised in America for much of their lives. For many, the official action of deportation may take a long while to go into effect. Therefore, the anticipation of deportation also presents many (mental health) concerns as well. 

    Sourced from: The Southeast Asia Resource Action Center: Fact Sheet. The Devastating Impact of Deportation on Southeast Asian Americans A Community of Refugees. (n.d.). https://www.searac.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/The-Devastating-Impact-of-Deportation-on-Southeast-Asian-Americans-1.pdf 

    This lesson contains content that may be sensitive for some students. Teachers should exercise discretion in evaluating whether the resources are suitable for their class and provide a content warning to their students at the beginning of the lesson. The lesson contains content about violence, mental health, and trauma.

    Image Citation: The School-to-Deportation pipeline. (n.d.). Learning for Justice. https://www.learningforjustice.org/magazine/fall-2018/the-school-to-deportation-pipeline 

    Historical Thinking Skills

    This lesson will facilitate student proficiency in historical significance, one of Seixas’ historical thinking skills (Seixas & Morton, 2013). Students make personal decisions about what is historically significant, and then consider the criteria they use to make those decisions. Students consider how events, people, or developments have historical significance if they resulted in change. That is, they had deep consequences, for many people, over a long period of time.

    Supplies
    • Access to laptop device
    • “Southeast Deportation Pipeline” slide deck, suggested text in lesson
    Videos
    • “Why I Write” 

    Accompanying slides for this lesson may be found here: https://ucdavis.box.com/s/vtwmv48ue3a56rjuxpo00hfbkueevb8e 

    1. Cultural Enrichment: Oral History Video (7 minutes)
    • Teacher to provide brief context: We’ll be watching this spoken word poem by Kosal Khiev, a Cambodian refugee deported to his home country. 
    • Watch: "Why I Write" by Kosal Khiev (7 minutes) 
    • As students watch, ask them to jot down three or four words to describe how they felt or any thoughts about this story. 
    • Share with a partner.  
    • Teacher to introduce lesson objectives and lesson questions. Based on what they observed in the video, have students make a prediction as to what they will uncover as it pertains to the lesson question.
    1. Shared Learning (20–30 minutes)
    • Teacher to provide the following information to students (suggested in slides format). Recommended for teachers to share the presentation with discussion. Teachers can screencast the presentation so students can pre-watch and re-watch or interact with them independently. Ask students to explain what the content means after each slide.
      • Students follow along with the lesson by taking notes. Teachers can create a graphic organizer for students to use.
        • Title of Notes: Southeast Deportation Pipeline 
        • Opening question: When we think about crime, policing, and prisons, do we tend to think about Asian Americans? How does this harm different people? Who does this benefit?
        • Key terms: 
          • model minority: the Asian American stereotype of academic, economic, and cultural success in the United States
          • good refugee: a stereotype specific to Vietnamese refugees who were rescued by the US military and can assimilate quickly into US society 
            • The experiences of criminalized refugees contradict these stereotypes. 
      • History: 
        • In the 1980s and 1990s, Southeast Asian refugees fled war in Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia to resettle in the United States.
        • What was going on in the US at that time? 
          • 1960s-onward: Lyndon B. Johnson announces a War on Crime, which would lead to the massive expansion of the prison system in the next few decades.
          • 1970s-1980s: Richard Nixon instills the War on Drugs: spending trillions of dollars to increase policing and punishment for drug use, often targeting Black communities. 
          • 1990s: President Bill Clinton instills welfare cuts that left communities of color in poverty and drove them to crimes of desperation. 
          • 1990s: Clinton also passes even harsher criminal justice laws: 
            • Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 (IIRAIRA) - made undocumented immigrants and non-citizens with aggravated felonies eligible for deportation. 
            • Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA) of 1996 - expanded category of aggravated felonies. 
            • These policies were also retroactive, meaning noncitizens could be deported for crimes committed before 1996.
        • Because of all of these policies, Southeast Asian refugees entered the prison system. Today, over 14,000 Southeast Asian refugees live with active deportation orders 
          • To what degree were the consequences of these policies on Vietnamese Americans intended or unintended? Who did or did not have power agency in relation to these policies? Who made these decisions and who was impacted by them?
        • Asian Pacific Islanders in the Prison System 
          • It is difficult to track Asians and Pacific Islanders in the prison system, because they’re grouped together under the "Other" category. 
            • The Model minority stereotype erases their struggles. 
          • From 2019-2021, the Asian Prisoner Support Committee collected surveys from 513 incarcerated and formerly incarcerated API individuals across California. 
            • Vietnamese Americans were the most common ethnicity of respondents. 
            • Using this data, let’s unpack the migration to deportation pipeline.
        • Migration - School - Prison - Deportation Pipeline 
          • Have students heard of the school-to-prison pipeline? This is a framework that activists use to describe how Southeast Asian refugees get caught in the criminal legal system and immigration system. 
          • (1) Migration
            • The first step of the pipeline is migration, or the reasons why Southeast Asian refugees originally came to the United States. Most of the respondents fled war, genocide, political persecution, and poverty in their homelands. 
          • (2) School
            • Southeast Asian youth, along with other API respondents, also faced issues with bullying, language barriers, and lack of counseling. 
          • (3) Prison 
            • In prison, more API individuals, on average, tend to serve life sentences. Their needs are often unmet because their ethnic groups are not counted in prison data. 
          • (4) Deportation
            • Even after serving their sentences, Southeast Asians are disproportionately at risk for deportation instead of coming home to their families.
            • Many fear being deported to a country that they have no ties to, since their families are now in California and the United States. 
    1. Interaction with source (10–15 minutes)
    1. Community Collaboration (10–15 minutes)
    • Divide students into four groups, based on the four main points of the timeline: Migration, School, Prison, Deportation. 
      • In each of their groups, students will use their notes to list the main ideas of each point.
      • Regroup as a class, share main ideas out loud, fill in gaps of understanding.
    1. Cultural Production (20–30 minutes)
    • Students will create an infographic based on one of the following categories: migration, school, prison, and deportation. The infographic must contain the main idea from the lecture, as well as statistics to supplement the information. 
      • Alternatively, students can draw an illustration to reflect one of the categories. The final product can be open to a written, visual, or audio narrative.
    • Statistic requirements up to teacher discretion 
    • Infographic should include but is not limited to the following: 
      • Title of Assigned Category
      • One to two Main Idea Statements 
      • Statistics 
      • Images 
      • Two to four sources and appropriate citations
      • Suggested site to create infographic: Canva, Adobe, Google Drawings
    1. Conclusive Activity: Critical Circular Exchange - Share Time (5–10 minutes)
    • Groups to share infographic 
      • Options for sharing - Student can print infographic and post for gallery walk, student can leave full screen on device, student can provide link made available to whole class. 

    Students will create an infographic based on one of the following categories: migration, school, prison, and deportation. The infographic must contain the main ideas from the lesson materials, as well as statistics to supplement the information. Alternatively, students can draw an illustration to reflect one of those categories.

    • Engagement: Consider the following method to support with lesson engagement:
      • Create cooperative learning groups with clear goals, roles, and responsibilities
    • Representation: Consider the following method to support with multiple means of representation:
      • Display information in a flexible format so that the following perceptual features can be varied: 
        • The size of text, images, graphs, tables, or other visual content 
        • The contrast between background and text or image 
        • The color used for information or emphasis 
        • The volume or rate of speech or sound 
        • The speed or timing of video, animation, sound, simulations, etc. 
        • The layout of visual or other elements 
        • The font used for print materials
    • Action and Expression: Consider the following method to support in presenting their learning in multiple ways:
      • Provide models or examples of the process and product of goal-setting
      • Provide graphic organizers and templates for data collection and organizing information

    For additional ideas to support your students, check out the UDL Guidelines at CAST, 2018 http://udlguidelines.cast.org.

    • Emerging: Consider the following method to support with emerging students:
      • Listening: Label visuals and objects with target vocabulary 
        • Students use a Frayer graphic organizer to support understanding of a key word or concept. Place the target word in the center amid four surrounding quadrants to support different facets of word meaning.
    • Expanding: Consider the following method to support with expanding students:
      • Listening: Check comprehension of all students frequently 
        • Teacher paraphrases student responses as they explain their thinking in effort to validate content learning and encourage the use of precise language.
    • Bridging: Consider the following method to support with bridging students:
      • Listening: Confirm students’ prior knowledge of content topics 
        • With a focus on meaning­-making, students are prompted to think about what they already know in effort to help them learn something new.

    For additional guidance around scaffolding for multilingual learners, please consult the following resources:

    1. Fighting for Freedom Activity - One pagers on movement leaders. In groups of three, students will choose one of the following: California bills, organizations, or movement leaders working to stop deportations. Students will create a one-pager summary and a poster to present to the class. When groups finish, they can post their one-pager onto the wall. At the end of class, students will do a gallery walk to learn about different organizations, people, and bills in their community. Additional Option for Ticket out the door: Pick one organization that you learned about today, could be yours or someone else’s. Why did they resonate with you?  
    2. Advocacy Events - Have students research local community advocacy events related to combatting deportations. 
    3. Healing Circle - After going through this loaded lesson, have students look into healing activities that may be beneficial to individuals impacted by this deportation pipeline. In a visual infographic, students can create a collage of suggested, positive activities. The infographic can also include a list of community resources that may be of support. 

    API RISE. (n.d.). API-RISE-Community. API RISE. Retrieved July 28, 2023. https://www.api-rise.org 

    Asian Prisoners Support Committee (ASPC). (n.d.). APSC Survey Data. ASPC. Retrieved July 28, 2023. https://www.asianprisonersupport.com/apsc-survey-data 

    Asian Prisoners Support Committee (ASPC).  2023, March 21. Mission & History. ASPC. https://www.asianprisonersupport.com 

    Britt, K. 2020, May 11. English learner toolkit of strategies. California County Superintendents. https://cacountysupts.org/english-learner-toolkit-of-strategies/

    California Department of Education & English Learner Support Division. (2012). California English Language Development standards (Electronic Edition) kindergarten through grade 12 (F. Ong & J. McLean, Eds.). California Department of Education. https://www.cde.ca.gov/sp/el/er/documents/eldstndspublication14.pdf

    California Educators Together. (n.d.). ELA / ELD framework. https://www.caeducatorstogether.org/resources/6537/ela-eld-framework

    CAST. 2018. The UDL guidelines. http://udlguidelines.cast.org

    Espiritu, Y.L. 2014. Body counts: The Vietnam War and militarized refuge(es). University of California Press.

    Hinton, E.K. 2016. From the war on poverty to the war on crime: The making of mass incarceration in America. Harvard University Press.

    Hodge, J., & Dholakia, N. 2021, June 17. Fifty Years Ago Today, President Nixon Declared the War on Drugs. Vera Institute of Justice. https://www.vera.org/news/fifty-years-ago-today-president-nixon-declared-the-war-on-drugs

    San Diego County Office of Education. (n.d.). Providing appropriate scaffoldinghttps://www.sdcoe.net/educators/multilingual-education-and-global-achievement/oracy-toolkit/providing-appropriate-scaffolding#scaffolding

    Sexias, P. & Morton, T. 2013. The big six: Historical thinking concepts. Nelson Education.

    Studio Revolt (Director). 2011, October 30. Why I Write: Verses in Exile #1 / Kosal Khiev’s video debut. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YstoXrrz1Gs

    Southeast Asian Research Action Center. (n.d.). The Devastating Impact of Deportation on Southeast Asian Americans. Southeast Asian Research Action Center. https://www.searac.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/The-Devastating-Impact-of-Deportation-on-Southeast-Asian-Americans-1.pdf

    Southeast Asian Research Action Center (SEARAC). (n.d.) Southeast Asian Americans and Deportation Policy. SEARAC. https://www.searac.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Southeast-Asian-Americans-and-Deportation-Policy_8.8.2013.pdf

    Southeast Asian Research Action Center (SEARAC). (n.d.). Southeast Asian Americans and the School-to-Prison-to-Deportation Pipeline. SEARAC. https://www.searac.org/programming/national-state-policy-advocacy/immigration/#:~:text=Southeast%20Asian%20Americans%20and%20the%20School%2Dto%2DPrison%2Dto%2DDeportation%20Pipeline

    Studio Revolt. 2011, October 30. Why I Write: Verses in Exile #1 / Kosal Khiev’s video debut. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YstoXrrz1Gs 

    Tulare County Office of Education. (n.d.). Strategies for ELD. https://commoncore.tcoe.org/Content/Public/doc/Alpha-CollectionofELDStrategies.pdf 

    VietRISE. (n.d.). VietRISE | Advancing social justice in Orange County. Retrieved July 28, 2023, from https://vietrise.org/

    Wilson, E.S. 2021, September 27. Ke’s Story: Accepting and healing from harm, but fearing deportation. SEARAC. https://www.searac.org/our-voices/community-stories/kes-story-accepting-and-healing-from-harm-but-fearing-deportation/

    Supplementary Sources 

    California Bill Would Protect Immigrants Freed Under Criminal Justice Reforms From Being Handed to ICE. (n.d.). KQED. https://www.kqed.org/news/11946255/california-bill-would-protect-immigrants-freed-under-criminal-justice-reforms-from-being-handed-to-ice 

    Hendricks, T. 2023, April 11. California Bill Would Protect Immigrants Freed Under Criminal Justice Reforms From Being Handed to ICE. KQED. https://www.kqed.org/news/11946255/california-bill-would-protect-immigrants-freed-under-criminal-justice-reforms-from-being-handed-to-ice 

    Law, V. 2022, December 21. These Incarcerated Organizers Won Their Freedom. Now They Face Deportation. Truthout. https://truthout.org/articles/these-incarcerated-organizers-won-their-freedom-now-they-face-deportation/

    Southeast Asian Research Action Center (SEARAC). 2020, September 28. Vietnamese Refugee, Tin Nguyễn, is Released from Adelanto ICE Detention Center. SEARAC. https://vietrise.org/press-release-vietnamese-refugee-tin-Nguyễn-is-released-from-adelanto-ice-detention-center/  

    PRESS RELEASE: Vietnamese Refugee, Tin Nguyễn, is Released from Adelanto ICE Detention Center | VietRISE. (n.d.). Retrieved September 18, 2023. https://vietrise.org/press-release-vietnamese-refugee-tin-nguyen-is-released-from-adelanto-ice-detention-center/ 

    Model Curriculum

    Standard(s)

    Grade(s)