The First Republic: Hopes and Visions for a New Nation

    Overview

    The First Republic: Hopes and Visions for a New Nation

    Protest at National Assembly Opera house

    Author: Joseph Nguyễn
    Grades: 9-11

    Suggested Amount of Time: 55-70 Minutes
    Area of Study: Social and Political Transformations in Twentieth Century Vietnam

    Compelling Question
    • How did French colonialism, political ideologies and geopolitics shape the internal divisions of Vietnam?

    Lesson Questions
    • How did contending political ideologies and geopolitical divides such as, but not limited to, nationalism, modernity, republicanism, and communism shape the internal divisions of Vietnam from 1954 to 1975?
    • How is the diversity of culture, society, and politics expressed in the Republic of Vietnam and how do those legacies influence the Vietnamese refugee community today?
    • What were the feelings, hopes, and visions of the Vietnamese people in the early stages of the Republic of Vietnam and how do they influence those of the Vietnamese refugee community today?
    • What are key aspects of culture, society, education, civic engagement, and life in the First Republic (1955–1963) that help us understand the Vietnamese refugee community today?
    Lesson Objective

    Students will be able to describe the cultural attitudes and visions of the Vietnamese American refugee community that stem from the early stages of the Republic of Vietnam by analyzing literary and musical text and producing a medium of choice.

    Lesson Background

    The Republic of Vietnam (The First Republic) was founded in October 1955 under the leadership of President Ngô Ðình Diệm and with the support of many Vietnamese political groups. The republic that Ngô Ðình Diệm founded was not created from scratch; instead, it inherited the remnants of both the colonial bureaucracy and the French-trained Vietnamese military. Its territory extended up to the seventeenth parallel—the effective border with the communist DRV in the North—and contained roughly fourteen million inhabitants, including, at least initially, a small number of committed communist partisans.

    The newborn Southern republic initially seemed outmatched. Its most intractable challenge was to secure widespread popular legitimacy. In addition to a number of military, social, and political reforms implemented by Ngô Ðình Diệm’s new government, the Vietnamese people in South Vietnam, who had finally achieved their first independent nation after decades of colonial rule, took it upon themselves to build the Republic of Vietnam as a nation worthy of being the true representative for the values of freedom, humanity, and liberalism espoused by the First Republic for the Vietnamese people. Sentimentalist nationalism in literature, art, and music, emphasizing human emotions and personal relationships of love were metaphorical to their attitudes towards the nation, were key cultural elements during these early stages that continue in the Vietnamese American community today.

    Despite these daunting odds, the state proved relatively capable during its first five years in power. South Vietnam achieved a degree of political stability and military security, enabling notable economic and cultural development. The economic transition from French control to Vietnamese sovereignty went relatively smoothly, complemented by educational reforms aimed at asserting a postcolonial Vietnamese national identity. The migration of Northern writers, artists, and intellectuals to the South also stimulated new ideas and movements such as the Sáng Tạo (Creativity) literary group and the magazine Bách Khoa (Polytechnics). New music adapted from Western and Eastern sounds also attained its own special characteristic in the new society.

    *Lesson background adapted from: Vũ, Tường, & Fear, Sean (Eds.). 2020. The Republic of Vietnam, 1955–1975: Vietnamese Perspectives on Nation Building. Cornell University Press.

    Image Citation: Protest at National Assembly Opera house | Virtual Saigon. (n.d.). Virtual-Saigon.net. Retrieved October 24, 2023, from https://virtual-saigon.net/Photos/Images?ID=27816

    Ethnic Studies Theme

    This lesson connects to the ethnic studies theme of reclamation and joy from the Asian American Studies Curriculum Framework (Asian American Research Initiative, 2022). Students explore the ways that communities reclaim histories through art, cultural expression, and counternarratives. Students discuss how Vietnamese communities create a collective hope for a new nation by sharing their own struggles, resilience, and hopes through music and other creative expressions.

    For additional guidance around ethnic studies implementation, refer to the Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum (2021) https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/cr/cf/esmc.asp.

     
    Historical Thinking Skills

    This lesson will facilitate student proficiency in historical perspectives, one of Seixas’ historical thinking skills (Seixas & Morton, 2013). To demonstrate the use of evidence to write historical fiction that accurately conveys the beliefs, values, and motivations of historical actors. Students consider why it is important to avoid presentism, the imposition of present ideas on actors in the past. Nonetheless, cautious reference to universal human experience can help us relate to the experiences of historical actors.

    Supplies
    • Access to laptop device
    Readings
    • Mai Thảo  “Sài Gòn: Vietnam's Cultural Capital” 
    • Tình Hoài Hương - Phạm Duy Lyrics
    Videos
    • Liên Khúc Quân Hành Việt Nam Cộng Hòa
    • 1958 - President Diệm’s Motorcade Passes By Troops In Formation At An Independence Celebration 
    • Nostalgia for the Homeland (Tình Hoài Hương) Phạm Duy or Tình Hoài Hương (Phạm Duy) PBN 111 Opening
    Handouts
    1. Warm-Up (five minutes)
      1. Prompt students to consider the following prompt: What are two dreams you have for the future? This can be dreams about your own future, or dreams for the place we live in.
      2. Have students share with a partner, then have a whole class share out. 
    2. Class Opener (five to eight minutes) 
      1. Optional: Before class, the teacher can play nationalistic music from the Republic of Vietnam. Teacher can begin the class with a slide, “Welcome to the new Vietnamese nation: the Republic of Vietnam!”
      2. Possible music video before class can be found here (taken from Thúy Nga productions): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-qZZQxS3Qc
      3. When class begins, the teacher will play a video showing the third year anniversary of independence and formation of the Republic of Vietnam in 1958.
        1. Video can be found at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFvl5mKDlnI 
        2. With the classroom setting (videos and background music), the teacher will write the prompt the students to take on this point of view:
          1. You are a Vietnamese American remembering your past. It is 1955. You have either lived in South Vietnam your whole life under French and Japanese colonial rule, or have just escaped the communist North as part of the one million Northern refugees in the North-South migration of 1954. After years as a French colony and conflict, you finally are now a full Vietnamese citizen, of an independent, Vietnamese nation that you have dreamed your whole life about. Write down all the emotions you must have felt during that time, for both yourself and the future of your new country. Anxious? Excited? Nationalistic? Apathetic?
        3. Students will take one to two minutes to write down their answers, or students can discuss with a peer
        4. Then, the teacher will call on some students to share what some present-day Vietnamese Americans must have felt during that time.
          1. The teacher should guide the discussion to point out the excitement of having one’s own nation for the first time, the belief that we as a Vietnamese people could do anything, anxieties for the future due to the separation of Vietnam into two countries, nostalgia for one’s home and hopes to reunite with family (especially for North Vietnamese migrants), and hopes for the future.
    3. Interaction with first source: Analyze “Sài Gòn: Cultural Capital of Vietnam” (20 minutes)
      1. The teacher will pass out the article, “Sài Gòn: Vietnam's Cultural Capital” by Mai Thảo, a Northern Vietnamese migrant in 1954 who left Vietnam by boat in 1977, known for being one of the most renowned literary writers in the Republic of Vietnam and in the US. 
        1. The article can be found in the handouts.
      2. The teacher will briefly go over the biography of Mai Thảo as a Northern migrant in 1954 and Vietnamese boat person as well as an overview of the article (five minutes).
        1. Biography: Mai Thảo's real name is Nguyễn Đăng Quý, with other pen names including Nguyễn Đăng. In 1954, he migrated to South Vietnam, writing short stories for various newspapers such as Dân Chu, Lửa Việt, and Người Việt. He served as the editor-in-chief of Sáng Tạo (1956) and Nghệ Thuật (1965) newspapers, and from 1974, he oversaw the Văn newspaper. He participated in the arts and literature programs on various radio stations in Sài Gòn from 1960 to 1975. On December 4, 1977, Mai Thảo fled Vietnam by boat. After seven days and nights at sea, the boat arrived at Pulau Besar, Malaysia. In early 1978, he was sponsored by his sibling to move to the United States. Soon after, he collaborated with Thanh Nam's Đất Mới newspaper and other overseas publications. Mai Thảo loved poetry, memorized it, and wrote many long poems from the age of 16 or 17, even writing poetic dramas. In July 1982, he republished the Van magazine and served as its editor-in-chief until 1996, when he handed it over to Nguyen Xuan Hoang due to health issues. He passed away in Santa Ana, California on January 10, 1998.
        2. Background description: “Sài Gòn: Vietnam’s Cultural Capital” is an article from the perspective of a Northern Vietnamese migrant in 1954. Before the division of the country by the Geneva Accords in 1954, Hà Nội, based in North Vietnam, was considered the cultural, intellectual, and artistic capital of Vietnam. However, due to fears of communist repression, some of Vietnam’s most renowned musicians, composers, writers, poets, and artists left for Hà Nội to Sài Gòn in 1954.The article emphasizes sadness for the fact Hà Nội is no longer the cultural capital of Vietnam, as a Northern refugee/migrant, there is also much hope in rebuilding their lives in Sài Gòn, which they hope will become the new cultural capital of Vietnam. This hope is also a broader hope that the Republic of Vietnam will be a country that emphasizes the best of Vietnamese culture, arts, and literature. Although Sài Gòn fell to communist rule in 1975, Sài Gòn remains a symbol of that cultural and artistic vitality in Vietnamese refugee communities, especially in the United States. In Vietnamese American communities, many Northern Vietnamese migrants in 1954 are considered to be the epitome of that cultural vitality, where a large majority of writers, poets, musicians, and intellectuals in the Vietnamese American community can trace their ancestry back to North Vietnam in 1954.
      3. The teacher will give students time to read the article silently and take notes. 
      4. After reading, the teacher will divide students into pairs, and students will work together to discuss and write down their answers to the following questions: 
        1. What is the main idea of the article?
        2. What imagery does the author use to describe Sài Gòn as a cultural capital?
        3. Based on the article, what type of tone do you think the author, and many new Northern Vietnamese migrants, feel about their prospects in this new home, in the Republic of Vietnam?
      5. The class will come together, and students will share their thoughts about the article.
      6. The teacher should focus the discussion about how Vietnamese people in the Republic of Vietnam, especially Vietnamese Americans today, saw Sài Gòn and the Republic of Vietnam as the future and hope of the best of Vietnamese culture and society, and although there are many trials to come, most Vietnamese people did their utmost to create art, literature, and music befitting of the new cultural capital of the world.
      7. Teacher can also talk about how in 1975, Vietnamese Americans saw themselves as continuing to preserve the best of Vietnamese culture, just as they did in the Republic of Vietnam, including literature, art, and music that is produced overseas (this is a good transition to the next source/activity).
      8. The teacher can also use the information below to help give context to this new feeling of hope and idealism for the new Vietnamese nation and its people.
        1. Before 1954, Hà Nội was the political and cultural capital of French Indochina. After the Geneva accords, over 1 million Northern Vietnamese fled to the South, a sizable population part of the intellectual and literary elite from Hà Nội. Sài Gòn becomes the new “Hà Nội” as Vietnamese in the RVN wildly anxious to take charge of their new, independent nation.
        2. “Sài Gòn is no longer mere hands and feet; it has become a heart. Historic events have shifted the nation's focal point, and Sài Gòn now grows, supplanting a decaying Hà Nội as the epicenter that gathers goodwill and the collective efforts of existing cultural activities across all sectors.Sài Gòn, the cultural capital of Vietnam! From a phenomenon to a reality.The foundations of our national culture are laid here, arebeing cultivated here through our creative efforts – through the efforts of those who are currently present here. Throughthe creative endeavors of our fellow travelers from aroundthe world. Through the supportive contributions of our siblingnations, and the friendly cultural trends of the world.Sài Gònis distinct from any other capital in the world. Yet Sài Gòn is also one of the world's cultural capitals. On the map of our nation, we inscribe Sài Gòn: the cultural capital of our peopletoday and tomorrow.” -Mai Thảo, Sài Gòn, the Cultural Capital of Vietnam 
    4. Interaction with second source: Tình Hoài Hương (Longing for the Homeland) (20 minutes)
      1. After the teacher makes the connection between the vision of the Republic of Vietnam as the beacon for culture and freedom, while the Democratic Republic of Vietnam in the North is stifled, the teacher will play the music video: “Tình Hoài Hương” (Longing for the Homeland) by Phạm Duy, one of the most renowned composers in Vietnam and in the Vietnamese American community (10 minutes)
      2. The video (with subtitles) can be found at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DieT1PUfXCM
      3. Video (without subtitles) can be found at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EuNrKwz-Vqw
      4. Lyrics and description of the song can be found in the handout: “Tình Hoài Hương - Phạm Duy Lyrics”.
      5. The teacher will give background information that the song was written in 1952 to describe Phạm Duy's longing for the home in North Vietnam that he had to leave, but also the hope he has for his country and his homeland. In 1954, the song became extremely popular among the Northern migrant population in the South, and it became popular again among Vietnamese refugees after 1975. The song is a strong example of how the best of Vietnamese culture and the hopes for the nation have been transferred from Hà Nội to Sài Gòn and represent both longing of the past and a vision towards the future. While playing the video, the teacher will instruct students to highlight lyrics that represent the sentiments and feelings expressed by Mai Thảo about the new cultural capital and society. 
      6. After playing the video, the teacher will give students 1–2 minutes to discuss with a pair about what imagery or lyrics they found poignant and representative of the dreams and feelings of Vietnamese people in the new nation.
      7. The teacher will use the remaining time to have a discussion with the students. Possible discussion topics:
        1. How do you think these feelings expressed by Mai Thảo in the earlier article are represented through the imagery and lyrics of “Longing for the Homeland" by Phạm Duy?
        2. This video is a rendition, almost 70 years later, of Phạm Duy's song, by Thúy Nga productions, one of the largest Vietnamese language music entertainment companies that serves the Vietnamese diaspora, especially Vietnamese refugees. How do the feelings about the Republic of Vietnam during this time continue to be expressed today in the Vietnamese American community?
        3. Can segue into the way that Vietnamese Americans feel pride in the ideals, hopes, and visions for a Vietnamese nation beginning from the Republic of Vietnam to today, and how they see themselves as inheritors of those dreams.
        4. The teacher should emphasize sentimentalism, a new wave of art, music and literature in the Republic of Vietnam as a form of  free expression that contrasts with supposedly emotionless communism. This later led to the development of yellow music in the later stages of the Republic of Vietnam.
        5. Emphasize how sentimentalist art, literature, and music continued to be produced after 1975 in America with similar values and goals, especially in regards to how they see their role in contributing to American society as well as advocating for reform and advancement of Vietnam currently.
    5. Cultural Production (20 min)

      1. Students will create a matrix, or storyboard, with four images that best illustrate the feelings, hopes, and visions of the Vietnamese people in the early stages of the Republic of Vietnam. The images selected should be symbolic and students should construct a 2–3 sentence explanation for each image. Students can hand-draw the images, or complete this work digitally. The final product can be open to a written, visual, or audio narrative. 

      2. Once students have created their four image matrix, or storyboard, provide opportunities for students to share and present. This can be done as a Give One, Get One, Lines of Communication, or small group share out.

    Representation: Consider the following method to support with multiple means of representation:

    • Provide written transcripts for videos or auditory clips. 

     

    Action and Expression: Consider the following method to support in presenting their learning in multiple ways:

    •  Provide prompts and scaffolds to estimate effort, resources, and difficulty. 

     

    Engagement: Consider the following method to support with lesson engagement:

    • Invite personal response, evaluation and self-reflection to content and activities.

     

    For additional ideas to support your students, check out the UDL Guidelines at CAST (2018)  http://udlguidelines.cast.org.

    Emerging: Consider the following method to support with emerging students:

    • Speaking: Provide sentence frames for pair interactions
      • In response to a prompt, the teacher offers a sentence frame orally and/or in writing to support expression of student thinking. Frames are adjusted based upon specific grammatical structure, key vocabulary, content learning, and language proficiency level descriptors, etc. Frames are a temporary scaffold that require modification.

     

    Expanding: Consider the following method to support with expanding students:

    • Speaking: Repeat and expand student responses in a collaborative dialogue
      • In partner and group discussions, students use conversation moves to extend academic talk. Conversation moves help students add to or challenge what a partner says, question, clarify, paraphrase, support thinking with examples, synthesize conversation points, etc.

     

    Bridging: Consider the following method to support with bridging students:

    • Speaking: Require the use of academic language
      • In response to a prompt, the teacher offers a sentence frame orally and/or in writing to support expression of student thinking. Frames are adjusted based upon specific grammatical structure, key vocabulary, content learning, and language proficiency level descriptors, etc. Frames are a temporary scaffold that require modification.

     

    For additional guidance around scaffolding for multilingual learners, please consult the following resources:

    1. If historical context is needed for the First Republic, please refer to the following multi-dimensional narratives below about the Diệm government. Ensure that the sources you are using reflect the variety of both South Vietnamese and American narratives. (ex: Those in South Vietnam, Vietnamese American community, and American government had both members that supported, and those that actively fought against the Diệm government). Use the following sources when necessary:

     

    1. Rock N’Roll in the Republic of Vietnam - If the teacher or students are interested in delving deeper into culture, especially musical culture, of the Republic of Vietnam the teacher can use extra days to do activities with the rise of rock n’ roll in Vietnam and the growing cosmopolitan culture of Sài Gòn.

    American Initiative. 2022. Asian American Studies K-12 Frameworkhttps://asianamericanresearchinitiative.org/asian-american-studies-curriculum-framework/ 

    1958 - President Diệm’s Motorcade Passes By Troops In Formation At An Independence Celebration. (n.d.). www.youtube.com. Retrieved September 19, 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFvl5mKDlnI

    Britt, K. 2020, May 11. English learner toolkit of strategies. California County Superintendents.  https://cacountysupts.org/english-learner-toolkit-of-strategies/

    California Department of Education. 2021. Ethnic studies model curriculum. https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/cr/cf/esmc.asp 

    California Department of Education & English Learner Support Division. 2012. California English Language Development standards (Electronic Edition) kindergarten through grade 12 (F. Ong & J. McLean, Eds.). California Department of Education. https://www.cde.ca.gov/sp/el/er/documents/eldstndspublication14.pdf

    California Educators Together. (n.d.). ELA / ELD framework. https://www.caeducatorstogether.org/resources/6537/ela-eld-framework

    CAST. 2018. The UDL guidelines. http://udlguidelines.cast.org

    Duy, P. 1989. Hồi ký của Phạm Duy (Memoir of Phạm Duy). Anh Phu Minh Phát Publishing.

    Duy, P. 1952. Tình Hoài Hương (Longing for the Homeland) [Song].

    Liên Khúc Quân Hành Việt Nam Cộng Hòa. (n.d.). www.youtube.com. Retrieved September 19, 2023.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-qZZQxS3Qc 

    Mai Thảo. 1956, October. Sài Gòn Thủ Đô Văn Hóa Việt Nam (Sài Gòn: Vietnam's Cultural Capital). Sáng Tạo (Creativity), 1(1).

    Miller, E. 2013. Misalliance: Ngo Dinh Diem, the United States, and the Fate of South Vietnam. Harvard University Press.

    Nostalgia for the Homeland (Tình Hoài Hương) Phạm Duy. (n.d.). Www.youtube.com. Retrieved November 30, 2023.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DieT1PUfXCM

    Pond5. 1957. President Diệm's Motorcade Passes By Troops In Formation At An Independence Celebration [Video]. Editorial Rights given to Joseph Nguyễn. 

    Sài Gòn Thủ đô văn hoá Việt Nam. Mai Thảo. 2019, March 23. Người Tình Hư Vô.  https://nguoitinhhuvo.wordpress.com/2019/03/22/sai-gon-thu-do-van-hoa-viet-nam-mai-thao/

    San Diego County Office of Education. (n.d.). Providing appropriate scaffolding. https://www.sdcoe.net/educators/multilingual-education-and-global-achievement/oracy-toolkit/providing-appropriate-scaffolding#scaffolding

    Thúy Nga Productions. 2008. Ngày Quân Lưc VNCH 19- 6- 1973 (Day of the Republic of Vietnam Armed Forces 19-6-1973) [Video]. 

    Tình hoài hương. (n.d.). https://lyric.tkaraoke.com/17610/tinh_hoai_huong.html 

    Tình Hoài Hương (Phạm Duy) PBN 111 Opening. (n.d.). www.youtube.com. Retrieved November 30, 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EuNrKwz-Vqw

    Tran, N.A. & Vu, T. 2022. Building a Republican Nation in Vietnam, 1920–1963. University of Hawaii Press.

    Tulare County Office of Education. (n.d.). Strategies for ELD. https://commoncore.tcoe.org/Content/Public/doc/Alpha-CollectionofELDStrategies.pdf 

    Viet, H. C. (n.d.). Hờn anh giận em. Lời Bài Hát Việt Nam. https://lyrics.vn/lyrics/4348-hon-anh-gian-em.html

    Vu, T. & Fear, S. (Eds). 2020. The Republic of Vietnam, 1955–1975: Vietnamese Perspectives on Nation Building. Cornell University Press.

     
    Supplementary Sources

    Asia Entertainment Official. 2019, November 26. Hờn Anh Giận Em - Quốc Khanh & Ánh Minh | Liveshow ASIA Đón Giao Thừa [Video]. YouTube. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cK8XgdvmLLo 

    Gibbs, J. 2008. How does Hanoi rock? The way to rock and roll in Vietnam. Asian Music, 39(1), 5-25.

    Người Việt. 2013, June 23. Lễ tưởng niệm 50 năm HT Thích Quảng Ðức vị pháp vong thân. Người Việt. Available at: https://www.nguoi-viet.com/little-saigon/Le-tuong-niem-50-nam-HT-Thich-Quang-Duc-vi-phap-vong-than-1439/ 

    Prados, J. 2003, November 5. JFK and the Diem Coup. The National Security Archive. Available at:  https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB101/index.htm 

    Sexias, P. & Morton, T. 2013. The big six: Historical thinking concepts. Nelson Education.

    Viet Bao Foundation. 2016, January 11. Quận Cam: Lễ Tưởng Niệm Cố Tổng Thống Ngô Đình Diệm Và Các Chiến Hữu Quân Dân Cán Chính Việt Nam Cộng Hòa. Viet Bao Foundationhttps://vietbao.com/p113a259891/5/quan-cam-le-tuong-niem-co-tong-thong-ngo-dinh-diem-va-cac-chien-huu-quan-dan-can-chinh-viet-nam-cong-hoa 

    Thắng Hồ. 2021, September 23. Hờn Anh Giận Em (Jealousy) - Hùng Cường ft Mai Lệ Huyền - Vietnamese Classic Tracks Pre - 1975 [Audio]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=41XH0NYc08w 

    Tran, V. (Director). (n.d.). Tổng Thống Ngô Đình Diệm [Documentary Film]. SBTN. https://www.sbtngo.com/products/tong-thong-ngo-dinh-diem-bi-kich-cua-mot-nguoi-thm-hoa-cua-ca-dan-toc 

    Model Curriculum

    Standard(s)

    Grade(s)